Friday, June 15, 2007

why can you feel when you are close to remembering something?

There are plenty of models for how memory works at both a psychological and a physiological level. What I want to talk about now is a curious thing that happens with what is typically referred to as long-term memory. Long-term memory refers to the stuff that we remember for more than a few minutes - things like our phone number, the names of our friends, and where we live. These memories must be stored chemically in the brain. I think the current working model is that memories are somehow encoded in the strength and pattern of synapses, which are junctions between the neurons in our brains.

The curious thing about memory that I'd like to discuss now is (as you probably have inferred from the title) why can you feel when you are close to remembering something? In case you aren't with me, let me give an example. Let's say you're watching a movie; you see an actor that you've seen in many movies before, and your friend next to you says, "who's that actor?". If you know the actor extremely well, the name will flow off your tongue like a reflex. If you don't know the actor's name instantly, you will almost immediately get a feeling inside, like a gut instinct, that you can use to estimate if you'll probably come up with the actor's name if you think harder about it.

It's odd right? Somehow we can feel if further searching of our brain is likely to reveal that actor's name. And the feeling is relatively accurate. For example, I don't watch that many movies, but like many people I remember faces pretty well. So it's pretty common I'll recognize an actor's face in a movie, but I'll know that I have no idea what their name is. However, if I had previously learned the actor's name and the name was still at least weakly burned into my memory, I would get a sorta gut feeling for how likely I'd be able to dig that name out of my brain.

Ok, let's say we had a good feeling that we'd be able to find the actor's name if we think harder. What happens next?

We would start to search our brains around the areas of our brains where the actor is. Somehow we go to the memories we have for the actor, and we dig around and look through them. We'll see what other movies we can remember the actor in and what other actors we've seen him with. We can often even think of friends we know who would be able to help us answer the question. And then to move towards the actor's name, we might toss around names in our heads that feel right, so that we can listen to them and see if they sound right too. It is all a sorta fuzzy process that seems to move by intuition, but the intuition has a definite sense of direction. We can feel when we've made progress towards the name in our head even if we still do not know the name yet (e.g. we say, "I've almost got it, just give me a second"). When we do find the right name, it's like BAMM - after all that searching you've found the name, said it to yourself, and you get a sorta feeling of satisfaction that instantly lets you know that - yes that is the right name.

Why does this happen?

How does this work?


Chris Garay said...

J, I've thought about this a lot. I'm terrible at remembering names and I get the same feeling as to exactly how long it'll take me to recall a name.

There is a paper that describes a model for name and face recognition (and that includes the results of a PET study that shows different areas of the brain respond preferentially to either famous names and common names): The neural systems sustaining face and proper-name processing

The interesting aspect of name recollection is that there is a one-to-one relationship between a specific person or face and the proper name of that person, whereas "chair" or "television" describes a class of objects. It seems like there is a common pathway for the assignment of names to both objects and faces but that there is an increased processing demand for face recognition because of the uniqueness that we assign to each face. Overall, faces are very similar to one another but they require unique assignment of names. All chairs pretty much look like chairs and they share one common name.

I take this to imply that a certain threshold for the stimulus of a pathway is necessary for full recollection. The time we take to think of a name could just mean we cycle through associations that we have with the visual stimulus (the face) in order to give a more robust stimulus that will result in the completion of recall.

J said...

Thanks for the ref. However, the feeling happens with non-faces too. For example if you lose your keys or wallet, you can have a similar feeling of how long it's going to take you to find them. Similarly with trying to remember an address or a phone number you had many years ago. But it does seem like the feeling is more intense when it concerns people and faces.